50Plus-Today is more like a curated resource for adults age 50+ than a blog, and we are supported partially by our readers. When you buy via the links on our site, including amazon.com, we may earn an affiliate commission. We do not accept incentives for our reviews; all opinions are our own.
I’ve subscribed to just about every dating site ever created in the 8 years since my divorce. I’ve had a few good experiences, a few bad experiences and lots of mediocre experiences.
I was an active user of Match.com and OKCupid for three months over the holidays and into this New Year. I figured the holidays are when people are the loneliest and that would be a good time for me to connect with other lonely hearts. Much to my surprise I found exactly the opposite. I received an extraordinary amount of “likes” which resulted in a few conversations leading to meeting only 9 men. Out of these 9 men, I only had a second date with 2 of them, a third date with one of them and nothing beyond that.
Now, I know what you are thinking, “Meeting 9 men in a 90-day period of time is GREAT!” Now, let me put it into perspective with actual numbers: On Match.com, I received 673 likes resulting in 37 online conversations leading to 12 phone conversations with 6 actual meetings. I’m a statistics person and so the outcome of 90 days of being on Match.com translates to meeting .009% of the people that “liked” me. On OKCupid, I received 1,239 “likes” resulting in 56 online conversations leading to 15 phone conversations with 3 actual meetings. The outcome of 90 days on being OKCupid translates to meeting .002% of the people that “liked” me.
Because I am the eternal optimist with a rose-colored-glasses perspective, I thought, “maybe I’m on the wrong dating sites.”
Keep in mind, I was on these two sites over the holidays. Shouldn’t this be the absolute best time to be online? How many holiday parties have you attended stag because you were single? I wasn’t invited to ANY holiday parties. Not one single one. Not even New Year’s Eve. Many people make a resolution to find a new love in the new year so why should I be any different? I thought I will try 1 more site to see if the results are any different. I decided to try Bumble. This site is where the woman is required to contact the man first to begin the conversation. The man has 24 hours to respond and then the communication expires. After 2 weeks, I received 186 “likes” and attempted 12 conversations. I only had two responses and met one man. The outcome of being on Bumble for two weeks is .005% however based on the above stats, I would guess that number would decrease if I continued my membership.
The interesting thing about all of these sites was that I was “liked” by a few guys that I’ve spoken to and some I’ve actually met. I know people who have met online, and I do think it is a great platform; especially for busy people. One of the conclusions I have reached is that some people, men and women alike, use it as a distraction from boredom; at a stop light, in the line at the grocery store or bank, etc. It is a scroll and swipe technology that feeds the need to constantly be entertained and do something. The more we touch something, like our phones, the more emotionally attached we become to it. Another conclusion I’ve reached is that I’ve given online dating enough, time, energy and effort to realize, for me, I need to do something different.
As I was sharing my dating woes with my girlfriend and her husband who have been happily married for over 20 years, she made an incredibly insightful and bold statement. She said, “You are trying to put everything into a box. You are looking at a profile online and seeing how that man fits into this box you’ve created. There is something incredibly important that you are missing.” I looked at her husband and he began nodding his head vigorously; he knew what she was about to say.
“You are missing the one thing that you will never get online.”
“Think about how people used to meet before social media, cell phones and email. They made eye contact, smiled at each other and then started a conversation; providing a way for the senses to be engaged. During the conversation, feelings were activated through laughter, light-hearted talk, occasional serious subjects and a physical connection by being close to that person,” she explained. Suddenly, a lightbulb went off and I began to recognize a repeating pattern with myself. I was creating a story around who the person was before I ever met them based on their photos and what they had written in their profile. From the small percentage of men that I met, I was a bit disenchanted that they did not live up to the story that I created. To further complicate things, there was a huge disconnect between what they said and what they did. Their actions did not match their words. There are certain nuances you are able to pick up on when you meet someone in person, especially for the first time. I continually found that something was amiss when I met the man in the photos. Thinking about what my girlfriend said, I looked back at the men I met and asked myself, “Would I have wanted to meet this person if I saw them in person?” I would have had the opportunity to observe them; watching how they interacted with other people and then would have made the decision whether to introduce myself or not. Out of the ten men I’ve met, there was only one that I would have wanted to meet.
Interestingly, a few days later, I was able to experience this revelation in person. I met my girlfriend out for happy hour after a really tough day. I was dressed in my normal work attire; running pants and matching jacket with ballcap. I wasn’t paying attention to who was at the bar or what was happening. I was very focused on feeling sorry for myself and just needed some TLC from my friend. She looked across the bar and noticed an attractive guy looking at me. She pointed him out and I began to observe him; how he interacted with the other patrons and the staff. After a few times of our eyes meeting, I asked him to join us. During our conversation, I was able to get a feel for who he was; funny, polite, engaging and, most importantly, he spoke to both my girlfriend and I with respect. He, too, had some interesting and similar experiences with online dating and had decided to try meeting people the old-fashioned way. After a brief conversation that evening, we exchanged numbers and he asked to see me again. WOW! Success!!! We’ve had a couple of dates and have discovered that we have quite a bit in common including similar life and relationship goals.
Based on my experiences, my girlfriend’s advice and recommendations and this recent encounter, I am going to cancel my online dating site subscriptions.
I will head out bravely and boldly to meet men in person with the intent this will increase my odds of finding that special partner. After all, how can I utilize my senses to engage, connect and communicate with a man unless we are up close and personal? There are so many things I didn’t even realize I was missing in the online dating world especially how I want to feel in a relationship. In a way, I’ve had to relearn how to date, recognize what I’m willing to do to meet that special man and continue to make dating a priority. Another piece of valuable advice my girlfriend gave me was about not assessing during the date. She said focus on having fun and don’t think about what comes next. She told me that if you are continually assessing during the date it takes away from the joy of just being in the moment. She’s a wise woman who’s been married for over 20 years. I’m taking her advice and beginning again with a new and fresh outlook!
I’d love to hear any stories, feedback and perspective you may have from your dating experiences as well!
Amy Jones is a personal growth visionary, international speaker and author who lives and breathes one simple philosophy: live in the moment. For over two decades, she has inspired thousands of people; intent on helping facilitate their personal growth and self-healing process by creating opportunities for significant and lasting life changes through personal interactions, workshops and writing found on www.TheAmyJones.com